Fan Clutch

ehendrix

Member
Oct 21, 2013
12
Quick question, I am about to buy a fan clutch from Rock Auto, which is better the Dorman or the Hayden, the Hayden is about $20 more.

Thanks
 
It is a matter of preference. I have been running the Dorman for over 3 years now.
 
djthumper said:
It is a matter of preference. I have been running the Dorman for over 3 years now.

Sounds about right, just wanted to make sure if one is better than the other.

Thanks
 
There were reports that when Dorman first started making fan clutches for the aftermarket, they weren't 100% reliable. I had a Dorman engineer contact who was willing to do a thorough failure analysis if anyone would return one directly to him. Nobody ever did - they just got replacements from their parts store. For only $20 more, I'd take the Hayden, who was an (or perhaps THE) OEM supplier. That's what I put in when mine died.
 
If it makes a difference to you the Hayden is actually a Behr which is what came OEM and is made in the USA. Not sure where the Dorman is made. Check Amazon.
 
ehendrix said:
Quick question, I am about to buy a fan clutch from Rock Auto, which is better the Dorman or the Hayden, the Hayden is about $20 more.

Thanks

My Dorman crapped the bed last year after only 6 months of service. Got a P0495 with a constant CEL. Going to be replacing it before summer comes. Thankfully it has a lifetime warranty.

triz said:
If it makes a difference to you the Hayden is actually a Behr which is what came OEM and is made in the USA. Not sure where the Dorman is made. Check Amazon.

Hard to say. Amazon doesn't tell you. China parts are usually really cheap but most of the parts from Dorman are improved upon in certain cases. So if I had to take a guess it could be Mexico.
 
CaptainXL said:
My Dorman crapped the bed last year after only 6 months of service. Got a P0495 with a constant CEL. Going to be replacing it before summer comes. Thankfully it has a lifetime warranty.

As long as the next one lasts longer.

You may be saving straight-up $$$ with the lifetime warranty, but if time is money to you too, you're losing out every time you gotta run to the store or do the service. Depends on how you consider your time to be, though. :twocents:
 
IllogicTC said:
As long as the next one lasts longer.

You may be saving straight-up $$$ with the lifetime warranty, but if time is money to you too, you're losing out every time you gotta run to the store or do the service. Depends on how you consider your time to be, though. :twocents:

I am not a high flying businessman with a tight meeting schedule. I have plenty of time. I just got a dud. Besides I don't think I have a choice as Advanced Auto will not give me my money back...will they? I think it's just an exchange.
 
djthumper said:
It is a matter of preference. I have been running the Dorman for over 3 years now.

The Hayden has a 5 year /50K warranty. The Dorman is $50 less and has a lifetime warranty. So:undecided:
 
CaptainXL said:
The Hayden has a 5 year /50K warranty. The Dorman is $50 less and has a lifetime warranty. So:undecided:

I prefer the Hayden because its made in the USA.
 

Forum Statistics

Threads
24,339
Posts
649,433
Members
20,897
Latest member
Hollywood1929

Members Online